| Platinum | Jonny's Cookhouse |
| Gold | Auntie Dorns Take-Out |
| Gold | Pearles' In Paradise Take Out |
| Silver | Dairy Queen Grill & Chill |
| Bronze | Callisters Country Kitchen |
| Top Pick | 1 Scoop 2 Scoop |
| Top Pick | Footes Farm Market |
| Top Pick | Goucher's Farm Market |
| Top Pick | Hennigars Farm Market |
| Top Pick | The Real Scoop Ice Cream & Espresso Shop |