| Platinum | Mama Evelyn Pizzeria |
| Gold | Mama Sofia’s Pizzeria |
| Silver | House of Dough |
| Silver | Mama Sofia Pizzeria / Kingston |
| Bronze | Hole In The Wall |
| Top Pick | Big Mike's Pizza & Eatery |
| Top Pick | Boston Pizza |
| Top Pick | E-J's Grill & General Store |
| Top Pick | King Size Pizza |
| Top Pick | Natalino's Pizza |