| Platinum | Aunt Lisa's |
| Gold | Sweetest Memories - Candies, Gift, & More |
| Silver | Jonny's Cookhouse |
| Bronze | Canteen At The Lookoff |
| Bronze | Falmouth Scoop |
| Bronze | The Real Scoop Ice Cream & Espresso Shop |
| Top Pick | Callisters Country Kitchen |
| Top Pick | Hennigars Farm Market |
| Top Pick | Mantua Country Store |
| Top Pick | Swinimer D & W Convenience Store & Deli & Take-Out |